At face value, it can be easy to believe that a defamation of character lawsuit is at least a little frivolous. After all, how much damage could someone do by saying awful things about someone? These types of torts can be of extraordinary importance in your life.

One example is a woman who received a $500,000 judgment after someone claimed she caused the death of her child while drunk. In this example, the compensation obviously was not as crucial as protecting her reputation from enormous harm. She could have had a lifetime of problems finding employment or friends in Asheville, NC.

Nonetheless, understanding how to sue someone, specifically for defamation of character, requires understanding the legal mechanisms. After all, what does the law say about defamation of character? Reading this guide today will empower you to know the highlights of each part of the process. If you believe you have a case but want to know the details, now is the time to get started.

Schedule a Consultation With a Personal Injury Lawyer

This is truly the first step in how to sue someone for defamation of character. A personal injury attorney will typically listen to your situation and assess its potential for free. The topics they are likely to discuss during an initial consultation include:

  • Defamation Laws: You may hear a general summary of state laws and clarify their relevance to your circumstances.
  • Evidence Evaluation: The firm may need proof of your allegations. They usually ask for emails, texts, social media posts, or other records.
  • Damages Assessment: The attorney will assess the degree of harm done by the defamatory statement. This evaluation establishes the potential compensation.
  • Legal Fees: There will be an explanation of how they charge for their services. Many work on contingency fees or hourly rates, but you may consider having one on retainer.
  • Legal Options: After reviewing the information, the lawyer may discuss your legal choices. This conversation could involve deciding whether or not to take legal action.

The type of defamation lawsuit you might pursue should become clear. You will either have the decision to file a libel or slander complaint. Deciding between the two is an important step in how to sue someone for defamation of character.

Collect Evidence to Support Your Case

It would be miraculous if you had every piece of evidence with you during an initial consultation. The reality is, you may need to get creative about how to find details that will help your lawsuit. Providing your attorney with as much evidence as possible will increase the odds of a favorable outcome. Also, your personal injury lawyer may recommend hiring a private investigator.

First, any further context you can share about the defamatory statement is vital. The essentials include when it happened and the audience that received it. You don’t want details about how it may have instigated to be a surprise to your legal counsel in court.

Give your attorney names and contact information for any witnesses. These individuals may have heard the statement, seen it in writing, or know about the circumstances.

You may need an expert witness if your case involves complex issues. Your attorney can help identify and hire an expert if necessary.

Finally, evidence of your financial loss can be a boon to this type of litigation. You can provide evidence of the loss through bank statements, tax returns, or other financial records.

Send a Cease and Desist Letter

A cease and desist letter demands that the recipient stop making defamatory statements or face legal action. Here are the general steps a lawyer may follow when writing one for a client:

  1. Identify the client and the recipient of the letter.
  2. Describe the defamatory statements and how they are false and harmful to their client’s reputation.
  3. Demand that the recipient stop saying or writing anything further.
  4. Explain that legal action will happen if the recipient does not comply.
  5. Provide a deadline for the recipient to respond to the letter and comply.
  6. Include contact information for the recipient if they want to discuss the matter further.
  7. Send the letter to the recipient by certified mail or through a process server.

Cease and desist letters must follow legal requirements and accurately represent the client’s position. This potential liability means you need legal advice before writing and sending one.

File a Lawsuit

A civil complaint for defamation of character lawsuits includes several elements. The general goal is to present a compelling case of how the defendant’s actions harmed the plaintiff. The most key elements in how to sue someone for defamation of character.

First, the complaint starts with an introduction to the plaintiff and the defendant. It will also provide some background, like the relationship between the parties and the basis of the claim.

The petition will allege that the defendant made defamatory comments about the plaintiff. Your attorney will identify the specific defamatory statements and how they happened. Furthermore, the complaint will explain the falsehood and supply evidence.

Arguably the most crucial section will involve how the statements harmed the plaintiff. Consequently, it will also ask for damages for lost income, emotional distress, or harm to your reputation.

With these aspects stated, the complaint concludes with a request for relief. This portion outlines what the attorney wants the court to do. They could ask for an injunction, monetary damages, or other legal actions.

Consider Mediation

Mediation is a form of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) that can resolve the case before a trial starts. In this case, you wouldn’t need to know how to sue someone for defamation of character. Here’s how mediation typically works:

  1. Select a Mediator: Both parties will agree to select a neutral third party. They may be a retired judge, lawyer, or another qualified professional with experience.
  2. Preparation: Both parties will prepare a mediation statement outlining their position and evidence.
  3. Mediation Sessions: Most meetings occur in a private location. A conference room or an office building are frequent choices. The mediator will start by explaining the process and the ground rules.Then, each side will present its case.
  4. Negotiation: The mediator will work to negotiate a settlement. They will identify potential solutions, such as an apology or financial payment.
  5. Settlement Agreement: If the parties agree, they will draft a document that outlines the terms. It is not legally binding unless both parties sign it.
  6. Return to Litigation: If the parties cannot settle, the case proceeds to a trial. The mediator will not have further involvement in the litigation when this happens.

Go to Trial

Your attorney will advise you on the odds of a jury trial versus a bench trial before the trial begins. If they believe they have a judge that favors your case, they may suggest the latter. But, when your peers are more likely to side with you, that calls for a jury.

If you request a jury, both sides will select the panel through voir dire. This term refers to picking the individuals who will serve. Attorneys will ask questions to determine their suitability and try to get people more likely to see things their way.

Then, it is time for opening statements. The plaintiff’s lawyer starts by identifying the facts of the case and why the lawsuit began. The defendant’s attorney will have an opportunity to do the same.

Next, the plaintiff’s side will present their evidence and witnesses to support their assertions. During this period, the defendant’s lawyer will have the opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses. The defendant’s legal team will then present their evidence and witnesses to refute the plaintiff’s claims. Consequently, the plaintiff’s lawyer will have the opportunity to cross-examine also.

Closing arguments come next, which have similarities to the opening statement. Both sides summarize the evidence, witness testimony, and how the law is on their side.

During a jury trial, the judge will have the panel deliberate and reach a verdict. Otherwise, the final word on the matter is up to their discretion. If this critical point does not go your way, you can escalate by appealing to a higher court.

Learn More About How to Sue Someone for Defamation of Character

Does the information in this article feel overwhelming, or do you have more questions? Then we can connect you with a personal injury attorney near you that can provide answers.

You do not have to accept that someone has ruined your reputation forever. Request legal help through our site or call (866) 345-6784 to speak to a representative.

Return to the Blog

How It All Works

Call us or answer the questions on this site. Your category, location, and additional information will help us connect you to a legal professional and we’ll send you the results instantly.

Which Areas of Law?

We have attorneys in over 20 legal categories to choose from.

How Much Does This Cost?

We don’t charge you to be connected. Some legal categories require upfront fees while others do not. The legal professional will determine this with you before you commit to anything.